Are you saying that the trigger could possibly be tripping the hammer before the mainspring is fully compressed

Still havent tried swapping tanks yet.
Thank you everyone for all the suggestions so far.
No, what he said was that it could be possible that the sear is being tripped before the bolt/spring/hammer is all the way forward. If there is a few items that are a few thousands of an inch off from specs.
The main spring is totally compressed when you pull the pump arm back all the way and stays totally compressed during the entire travel forward until the sear makes contact with the trigger and it gets released.
PPS used to offer a trigger shoe with a set screw designed to limit the travel of the trigger. The idea was to set it so that the trigger would stop at exactly the release point. This would, in effect, give you the ability to overcome the problem mentioned above, if there is one.
First........you should try a different tank and reg.